Is the party over for ads on social networks?

With the wobble in Facebook’s monthly traffic suggesting that perhaps we are all getting tired of social networking (or then again maybe not), it was instructive to read Aaron Wall’s post on why social network traffic doesn’t monetise. The thrust of that argument is that advertising on social networks is typically not relevant to the interactions taking place in communities. As a result traffic quality is poor and hard to monetise.

It feels inevitable that there is going to be a backlash against the advertising-based business model of social networking. But if we accept that social networking as a medium (rather than any particular instances of it) is not going away and will continue to grow, it then becomes incumbent on online marketers to find better ways to engage the social graph. A new tool set is needed as the current tools are lacking …

For example Facebook promises that by using its ads you can “reach the exact audience you want with relevant targeted ads”. I would be really interested to hear people’s stories about whether these ads have been successful or not for them. My hunch is that simply having a well-targeted ad based on granular demographic data will not help conversion if it is blind to the social context it is served in.

The way to get that context is through participation in the conversations that your ‘audience’ is having. In other words join the party. The party metaphor is a great one for a community and quite insightful for online marketers. In the off-line world sponsorship and product placement work well as promotional tools at social events. Social networks offer plenty of opportunities to create branded/sponsored spaces for online conversations. And companies such as Blendtec (intentionally) and Coca-Cola and the Perfetti Van Melle Corporation - the maker of Mentos mints (unintentionally) have demonstrated the uplift in brand visibility and sales that comes when your product is at the heart of the online conversation.

So the message for online marketers is clear … as far as making money from social networking goes, the party is far from over … in fact it is just about to begin. Cocktails anyone?

Posted by Ivan Croxford on February 25, 2008

Tags: ads, Blendtec, Coke, communities, Facebook, Mentos, online advertising